Military Misdemeanours - Corruption, Incompetence, lust and downright stupidity, by Terry Crowd. A review by Chris.

It's always nice to see a QI-esque book hitting the shelves that provides an insightful look into the hidden facts of history that much of the mainstream history books leave behind. Terry Crowd's short book 'Military Misdemeanours' takes a sideswipe examination of the corruption, incompetence and downright daft things leaders, political figures and civilians have achieved throughout our history. From a witch trial that took place a few days before a Second World War engagement to a spy that was actually a transvestite, the reader is subjected to a plethora of witty and amusing anecdotes of history that should not be forgotten. The scope of research Crowd incorporates into the book is vast but what he selects to use as sources is rich. One of my personal favourites is the story of the Zimmerman Telegram - A German conspiracy plot to initiate the Mexican Goverment to invade the US in order to prohibit them from entering on the side of the allies in World War One. Although this is a story I am familiar with, Crowd provides a take on the incident that is fresh and new. This could possibly apply to many of the anecdotes throughout the book that have over time become common knowledge, but nonetheless, with the way Crowd uses the sources that are available to him, he provides a new spin on a familiar tale.

Apart from the book being slightly on the short side  it makes an interesting read on a quiet train journey.

***/3 Star

Chris

The Ebro 1938, by Chris Henry, Osprey Campaign Series 60.

These days, foreign visitors to Spain’s Ebro River are quite likely to be drawn there by the prospect of catching one of the huge Wels Catfish that populate this 565-mile long waterway.

Seventy-six years ago, thousands of young men from Germany, France, Morocco, Italy, America, Canada, Britain and Ireland were gathered along the banks of the Lower Aragon and Catalonian stretch of the river. However, these were not recreational anglers or tourists; they were part of two huge, rival Spanish armies totalling over 170,000 men involved in the longest and bloodiest battle of that country’s civil war.

The Ebro flows north to east from Cantabria to its delta near Tortosa in Catalonia where it joins the Mediterranean. Chris Henry’s account of this last great offensive operation of the Spanish Republic was originally published in 1999 and was the result of a year’s research in Spanish primary sources and archives. It remains, to my knowledge, the only English-language work on this campaign. (Please note, the map below and the photos in this post are not from the book.)

Though the Spanish Civil War started as a purely indigenous affair, beginning with a coup d’état by a group of right-wing army officers against the left-wing Popular Front coalition government of Spain’s Second Republic on 17 July 1936, it quickly captured the attention of the rest of the world; and many foreigners at the time saw it as heralding the first shots in the inevitable battle between the forces of reaction and the forces of revolution or between Fascism and Socialism.

As a consequence the governments of Nazi Germany and Mussolini’s Italy rapidly dispatched vital military aid in the form of aircraft, artillery, tanks, troops and technicians to General Franco’s rebels, known as the Nationalists. Leon Blum’s Popular Front government in France sent a small number of French-built fighter and bomber aircraft, but internal opposition and the lack of British support pushed them toward supporting the non-intervention agreement.

The Soviet Union soon became the main source of assistance to the Republic and during the autumn of 1936 large quantities of material began to arrive in Republican ports. While many of the weapons supplied by Stalin’s regime were antiquated and virtually useless, the aircraft, such the Polikarpov ‘Chato’ I-15 biplane and ‘Mosca’ I-16 monoplane fighters and the Tupolev ‘Katiushka’SB-2 bomber were the latest Soviet models and amongst the best warplanes of the time. Soviet supplied armour was also of a high standard and the T-26 and BT-5 tanks, both fitted with a 45mm gun, were more than a match for the German Panzer 1’s and the Italian CV33/35s that formed the bulk of the Nationalist tank force.

The supply of these aircraft, tanks and artillery came with conditions, chiefly the Republic had to allow some 2 – 3,000 military advisers and technicians such as the military attaché Vladimir Efimovich Gorev, the air force commander Yakov Smushkevich, and the tank brigade commander Dmitry Pavlov varying degrees of operational and tactical control of the Republican war effort.

Soviet influence was further strengthened by the Comintern-organized and controlled supply of foreign volunteers known as the International Brigades. Whilst their military significance has been exaggerated - they formed under 20% of the Army of the Ebro in 1938 for example - they did play a key role in preventing the fall of Madrid in November 1936 and were used as ‘shock troops’ in the subsequent battles in and around the Spanish capital in 1937.

In May 1937 Dr Juan Negrin replaced Largo Caballero as Prime Minister and although he wasn’t a Communist he did support closer Republican links with the Soviet Union and broadly accepted the Spanish Communist Party military/political strategy, which was also the Soviet Union line - the importance of ‘winning the war’ the need for ‘military hierarchy and order’ and the abandonment of the ‘social revolution’ and the centralized control of the previously independent political and trade-union militias

By early summer of 1938, the prospects for the Spanish Republic looked very bleak. The whole of the northern zone with the heavy industry and iron ore of Bilbao and the coal mining region of Asturias had been lost to Franco’s Nationalists by October 1937, whilst his Aragon Offensive of March/April 1938 came to a successful conclusion on 17 April 1938 when Navarrese troops reached the Mediterranean at Vinaroz thus splitting the Republican-held territory in two.

Monument to Dr Juan Negrin

It was at this point that the Republic had somewhat of a reprieve. First of all the French/Spanish border had been re-opened on 17 March 1938 thus allowing Soviet arms supplies to flow into Catalonia via France. Secondly on 5 July 1938 Franco chose to drive eastward to the Levant with the objective of capturing the new Republican capital, Valencia rather than attacking Catalonia as his German and Italian allies advised.

So despite their recent military setbacks Prime Minister Negrin and the Chief of Staff of the Ejército Popular de la República,  Vincente Rojo decided to launch another offensive in the summer of 1938 and this is the subject of Chris Henry’s concise study.

The objectives of the Ebro Offensive were to draw-away enemy troops from the Levant Offensive, to reunite the two halves of Republican Spain and to prolong the war until what appeared to many as the inevitable general European war broke out. This war would see Republican Spain aligned with France and Britain against Franco and the Fascist states of Italy and Germany.

The Battle of the Ebro began on the night/morning of the 24/25 July 1938 when the Autonomous Army of the Ebro carried out a series of meticulously planned crossings along a 40 mile front on the southern part of the river. With the aid of some excellent maps, alongside the now familiar Osprey ‘bird’s eye’ battle views plus a selection of the author’s own battlefield photographs the reader is better able to appreciate the rugged and harsh terrain over which the two armies fought.

Initially the Republican crossing of the Ebro and westward-advance was very successful and their sappers and engineers constructed a number of pontoon-bridges at various points along the river plus a wooden bridge at Asco and eventually an iron-bridge at Flix in the north-central sector, specially built to transport armoured vehicles.

The only unsuccessful part of the Ebro crossing was at Amposta in the far south close to the sea. Here the mainly French XIV International Brigade was badly mauled by the deadly rifle fire of General Juan Yague’s Moroccan Regulares. Some 60 men of the former were either killed or captured on the west bank of the river.

One of the initial objectives of the offensive was the town of Gandesa, a pivotal road and rail hub at the centre of the front and some 12 miles west of the Ebro. By the 26 July the XI, XIII and XV International Brigades, the latter included British/Irish, American and Canadian battalions got within 400m of the town and soon a furious to-and-fro struggle ensued for possession of the commanding height known as Puig de Aliga or Hill 481 which was a mile or so east of Gandesa. The XV International Brigade had occupied the hill on 25 July but was dislodged by a battalion of the Spanish Foreign Legion on 27 July and despite several counter-attacks over the next three days both the town of Gandesa and Hill 481 remained in Nationalist hands.

By 3 August 1938 the Republican field commander Lieutenant Colonel Juan Modesto in the face of growing numbers of Nationalist reinforcements decided to switch tactics to the defensive. The Republicans were still in control of a significant bridgehead on the west bank of the Ebro most importantly a series of 600m-high peaks in the Sierra de Pandols mountain range. From this date the Battle of the Ebro developed into a bloody attritional bloodbath that highlighted both the weaknesses of Republican operational thought and the sanguinary nature of Franco’s own poco a poco (little by little) strategic vision.

As Chris Henry highlights in his book, the Republican successes in the first three days of the offensive were achieved in spite of almost no operational air cover. Not until 30 July did the Polikarpov I-16 and I-16/10 ‘Super-Moscas’ make an appearance over the front. Even as late as 7 August 1938 there were only 70 of these machines operating in the skies above the Ebro.

In sharp contrast Nationalist aircraft were interdicting the bridges and pontoons on 26 July, hindering Republican supplies and tanks from reaching their comrades on the other side of the river. Very quickly the German Condor Legion, flying the best fighter of the day the Messerschmitt Bf109B and C variants were supporting the Dornier DO-17 and Heinkel 111B and Italian S-81 and SM79 bombers attacking the bridges at Flix and Asco and flying ground-attack missions against the Republican infantry. By the end of August 1938 the Nationalists had a total force of 500 fighters and bombers, including a handful of the new Junkers JU-87A dive bombers. The outnumbered Republican air force was unable to provide anything but token resistance and many of their planes were shot-down

This Nationalist aerial response was mirrored on the ground as thousands of infantry and 500 artillery pieces of from 65mm to 260mm were hastily redeployed to the battle sector in American-made trucks.

Many of Franco’s contemporaries including Hitler, Mussolini and the chief of the Nationalist air force, General Alfredo Kindelan, were highly critical of his policy of diverting troops from other sectors to engage in meat-grinder struggles to recover ground with little or no strategic value. However, as Professor Paul Preston has remarked, Franco wanted to deny the Republic any territorial gains, whatever the cost. His overall strategic goal was the long-term consolidation of his own political power and to achieve complete dominance over the enemy.

To this end he was unwittingly helped by his opponents who had chosen to carry-out a complex manouevre across a major river - with all the potential supply problems that could entail - and with clear material deficiencies in artillery and aircraft. In light of the experience of previous Republican offensive operations, Negrin and General Rojo’s Ebro plan appears at best ill-judged and at worst militarily irresponsible.

The earlier Battles of Brunete July 1937 and Teruel December 1937 to February 1938, both strategic defeats, had already demonstrated the tactical weaknesses of the Republican Army in attack. Here, initial success gained by surprise would be lost in a series of wasteful frontal assaults against some insignificant and weakly-held enemy position which would then allow the Nationalists time to bring up reserves and to launch deadly counter-attacks with their superior aerial forces and artillery which at Brunete decimated the Republican troops spread out as they were in open country.

Like Brunete and Teruel there was no shortage of bravery shown by the Republican troops when the relentless Nationalist counter-assaults started on 3 August 1938, and Enrique Lister’s 5 Corps’ stubborn defense of Hill 666 on the Sierra de Pandols mountain range from early August 1938 to 1 November 1938 was particularly heroic, especially so when one considers the constant artillery and aerial bombardment these men would have had to have endured. In the past three years excavation work prior to the installation of wind turbines in the La Fatarrella area north-east of Gandesa has unearthed the skeletons of several Republican soldiers buried in their trenches as they provided the rearguard for their comrades to complete the retreat back across the Ebro on 16 November 1938.

The Battle of the Ebro proved very costly in terms of Nationalist casualties (Paul Preston quotes over 6,000 killed in the battle as a whole) but these were fewer than the Republican losses in men and material (Preston records 7,000 dead) and furthermore the Republic’s losses were harder to make good, particularly as the French border was closed once more. Moreover, the European war that Negrin hoped would save the Republic was avoided by Neville Chamberlain’s diplomatic decision to sacrifice Czechoslovakia to avoid war with Germany at Munich on 30 September 1938, The Republic managed to limp on until Madrid fell in March 1939 but after the failure of the Ebro offensive General Franco’s victory was assured.

Peter

This is a review of The Wars of the Roses by Terence Wise, illustrated by Gerry Embleton.

This forty page colour book serves as a useful introduction to the Wars of the Roses. As can be expected of an Osprey book, it has a military and partly political focus rather than a social one. It begins by examining whether this was truly a civil war or actually a dynastic struggle between the Yorkist and Lancastrian houses. It then moves on to look at the ruling families and includes a useful lineage table that is both clear and easy to understand (which is no mean feat considering the complexity of the dynasties in this era.)

The book then goes on to look at the three main phases of the wars in more detail. The first, covering 1455-1464, involves the First Battle of St. Albans, and the battles of Northampton, Wakefield, Mortimer’s Cross, Second St. Albans, Towton and Hexham. Shortly after this, Edward of York secured his crown, married Elizabeth Woodville (against the wishes of Warwick ‘the Kingmaker’ who was trying to arrange a French marriage) and imprisoned King Henry VI in the Tower. The book includes maps of the battlefields, and shows placements of troops and their movements during the battle.

It then moves onto the second phase, 1469-1471. This mainly involves Warwick’s rebellion against Edward, and includes the battles of Barnet (at which Warwick died) and Tewkesbury. Barnet holds a special fascination for me. It was fought in thick fog, and where the right wing of each army overlapped the left wing of the other, over the course of the battle the two armies swung around. Because of the fog, the Lancastrian right ended up connecting with the rear of the centre section of its own army, leading to accusations of treason. Edward’s cavalry charge caused a Lancastrian rout, and Warwick and his brother were cut down and killed.

The following illustrations aren't from the book, but they show the swing of formations to almost right angles from their original positions.

The book then addresses the third phase, 1483-87, which deals with the death of Edward IV, the “Princes in the Tower” and Richard III’s brief reign, and examines the battles of Bosworth, Stoke, Blackheath and Exeter.

The rest of the book looks at the armies of the day, with photos of plate armour, styles of helmets and coloured plates of various types of soldiers and standards. As I have an interest in heraldry, I appreciated these plates—it made an interesting addition to pictures of weaponry. Wise also looks at liveries and badges, and concludes with a discussion of the scenes in the coloured plates accompanied by a few photographs of weapons used at the time.

Although it’s a somewhat thin book, it certainly doesn’t claim to be an all-encompassing study of the period, and it's a really good introduction for anyone who's interested in beginning an investigation into the era. As I also have an interest in archaeology, I wouldn’t have minded a few photos of any surviving archaeological evidence from the battles sites. But it’s a concise summary of the events leading up to the civil war, and I adore the maps of the battlefields. I spent many happy hours as a teenager drawing these onto cards and detailing the movements of the armies.

On a final note, reading once again about Edward’s marriage to Elizabeth Woodville against the advice of Warwick brought to mind A Game of Thrones and Robb Stark’s marriage to Jeyne Westerling against his mother’s advice. It is clear that George R R Martin drew heavily on this period and its warring houses for his novels, so I guess it’s no surprise that I love the series so much!

Freya